The Language
Working terms for how a team's ability to function can give way.
How to use this
Treat this page as a current working language, not a finished taxonomy.
Ask one question of whatever you're watching:
Can this team see what is happening, and can it do anything about it?
Two proposed dimensions
FSL currently uses two proposed dimensions to help distinguish different kinds of failure.
Clarity is whether the team's picture of what is happening is shared and stable.
Agency is how much a team can act on what it sees: whether it has options and initiative, and whether it can shape the game's direction rather than merely respond to it.
These are proposed dimensions used to distinguish Failure Patterns. They are not themselves the product of FSL. The patterns are provisional distinctions across those dimensions. They describe different ways a team's ability to function may be compromised.
Failure Patterns
Failure Patterns are the centre of the current vocabulary. They describe proposed conditions in which a team's ability to read, coordinate or act on the game is compromised. That compromise may involve deterioration, blockage or instability.
The categories themselves are hypotheses. Research may show that a proposed pattern is a distinct condition, a subtype of another pattern, a transition, a response to another condition, or not a useful distinction at all.
Failure does not mean bad, and it does not mean losing. A Failure Pattern is not a judgement about the quality of a team, and it does not imply that any outcome will follow. A team can be in a pattern while the score is unchanged, or while winning. A team can lose without showing any of them. They describe a behavioural condition, not a verdict on the players, the coach or the football.
These are descriptions only. What a pattern might call for is a separate question, below.
The current patterns are not assumed to be the same kind of object. Some may describe a condition, some a trajectory, and some a relationship between changing conditions. One purpose of the research is to find out whether they can legitimately sit together.
Fog
Clarity is deteriorating faster than Agency. Players struggle to read cues or coordinate, even where options may still exist.
Drift
Clarity and Agency loosen gradually. Shape softens, intentions blur, and no clear rupture occurs.
Stall
Clarity remains relatively intact; Agency is low. The team sees the problem but cannot turn that understanding into progression.
Scramble
Attempts to act outpace collective Clarity. Problems are solved locally rather than collectively.
Overheat
Agency runs ahead of Clarity. Initiative and intensity remain high while decisions become rushed or unstable.
Collapse
Clarity and Agency are both low. Structure breaks, roles dissolve, and the opponent increasingly determines the shape of play.
Exits
A pattern describes. An exit is a reading. The two should not be confused.
For any pattern you see, a second question can follow:
What direction of change does this pattern appear to call for?
This is an observer's reading of what the condition suggests, not advice, and not a claim about cause or remedy. It is exploratory: it is not an assumed consequence of the pattern, and it only makes sense once observers agree what the pattern is.
A provisional set of directions, defined by which axis they move:
Restore Clarity: make the picture shared and stable again
Restore Agency: create options and the ability to act
Rebalance: let Clarity catch up with Agency
Reduce demand: lower what is being asked of the team before rebuilding anything
Hold and watch: nothing yet; keep noticing
The expected pairings are written down in the Research page before any data is collected, so they can be wrong. Drift and Scramble are deliberately left open.
If practitioners give the same exit for every pattern, the patterns add nothing at this level. That would be a useful result.
Reference conditions
Failure is easier to recognise against what functioning looks like. These terms describe recognisable ways a team can organise and act when Clarity and Agency are available, and where a team might arrive after leaving a pattern. They are not the focus of FSL. They are included to provide contrast, not to create a second taxonomy of football behaviour.
Settle
Stabilise rhythm and regain orientation.
Contain
Constrain opponent options and preserve the team's shape.
Connect
Link players, ideas and intentions; build shared pictures and stable passing routes.
Ignite
Accelerate tempo and destabilise structure.
Slice
Break lines with precision to access new zones.
Command
Clarity and Agency are both high and sustained. The team maintains a shared picture, retains options and can continue to act on what it sees. It is a reference point, not a verdict of superiority.
These are working terms. Some may prove useful. Some may collapse into existing football language. Some may disappear. Ignite and Slice currently describe actions more than conditions and are the next to be rewritten or cut. Command is kept because the patterns need something to be measured from and against.
Transitions
A Transition is a visible shift in a team's behavioural condition: movement into, between, or out of a Failure Pattern.
The interesting question may not only be what a pattern looks like, but when and how a team enters or leaves it.
It may appear before any change in tactic or scoreline. It may not. That is an open question.
Some proposed patterns may turn out to be transitions or trajectories rather than conditions. That is one of the things the research is for.
Influences
What might be associated with movement toward, between or out of Failure Patterns.
Stability: spacing, scanning, calm. May be associated with Clarity holding or returning.
Advantage: pressing, overloads, verticality. May be associated with Agency rising.
Human: emotion, unpredictability. May shift Clarity or Agency in either direction.
These are deliberately provisional hypotheses, not established causes, and they may not survive as categories. Stability is closer to a condition, Advantage to a game situation and Human to a residual, so they are not yet the same kind of thing. A further question is whether particular influences go with particular patterns, or whether the same pattern can arrive by very different routes.