Can Better Words Help Us See How Teams Fail?

QUESTION · INVESTIGATING

Football teams rarely stop functioning all at once. More often, something begins to change. The connections between players become less reliable. Possession loses its purpose. Players seem unsure of what to do next, or the team struggles to turn what it recognises into meaningful action.

Coaches and analysts often notice these changes before they can explain them. They might say that a team has lost its way, become disconnected, lost control or stopped playing with clarity. These descriptions can feel right, but do they help us distinguish what is actually happening?

Can better words help us see more precisely how teams lose their capacity to function?

The idea

This question began with a simple observation: people who watch football closely often recognise when something is going wrong, but may describe the problem in different ways.

Two people might watch the same passage of play and reach very different conclusions. One sees a team lacking clarity; another sees a team lacking options. One sees hesitation; another sees a failure to coordinate. They may be noticing different things, or interpreting the same thing differently.

Perhaps some of these differences could be made clearer through a more precise shared language.

The proposition being explored is that teams can experience different kinds of functional breakdown, and that distinguishing between them might help coaches and analysts describe what they see, compare their interpretations and think more carefully about possible responses.

What do we mean by failure?

Failure here does not mean losing a match, making an individual mistake or playing badly.

It refers to a team losing some of its capacity to function: its ability to understand and respond to the demands of the game, coordinate its actions and influence what happens next.

A team can be winning and still experience this kind of breakdown. It can also be losing without having lost its capacity to function.

The distinction matters. The question is not simply whether a team is performing well, but what is happening to its ability to act as a team.

Current thinking

The first version of the Football Sense Language (FSL) framework explored two possible dimensions of team functioning:

  • Clarity — whether the team has a sufficiently shared and stable picture of what is happening.
  • Agency — the extent to which the team can act on what it sees, use its available options and shape the game.

These are proposed ways of understanding team functioning, not things that can be directly observed in the same way as a pass, a run or a change of possession.

From these dimensions, six provisional patterns of functional breakdown were proposed:

  • Fog
  • Drift
  • Stall
  • Scramble
  • Overheat
  • Collapse

They are working ideas, not an established taxonomy. An important part of the investigation is whether they describe genuinely distinguishable situations, whether they overlap, and whether some should be changed or discarded.

What are we trying to find out?

  1. Can people identify when a team is losing some aspect of its capacity to function?
  2. Can they describe what they see without relying on assumptions about players' intentions or understanding?
  3. Can different patterns of breakdown be distinguished from one another?
  4. Can independent observers use the language consistently, and where do their interpretations differ?
  5. Do these distinctions lead to more precise questions or better-informed coaching and analysis?

These questions need to be approached separately. Agreement between observers would not, by itself, demonstrate that a category is valid. Nor would a useful label necessarily explain why a team is experiencing a particular problem.

What might challenge the idea?

The framework should not be treated as correct simply because its descriptions sound plausible.

It would be challenged if observers consistently found that the proposed patterns did not fit what they saw; if different patterns could not be reliably distinguished; if existing football language described the situations just as well; or if the additional distinctions made no difference to how people understood or responded to them.

It is also possible that what appears to be a lack of clarity or agency has another explanation entirely: unclear responsibilities, limited technical options, opposition pressure or constraints within the game.

Those alternatives need to remain open.

Where the investigation stands

The first informal exercise explored how people described a short passage of football before being introduced to the proposed framework. Ten people took part. Their responses were varied, and some felt that the available descriptions did not quite capture what they had seen.

This was an early exploratory exercise, not a test of the framework's reliability or validity. It did, however, reinforce the need to understand how people describe the same situations in their own words before asking them to use a predefined vocabulary.

The next stage is to develop a small, carefully defined pilot. Its purpose is to test whether the proposed distinctions can be used in practice, where observers disagree, and whether the framework adds anything to an open description of the game.

The categories may change. The dimensions may change. The framework may ultimately prove unnecessary.

The question remains worth pursuing either way.

The aim is not to create another vocabulary for football's sake. It is to find out whether more precise language can help us notice, distinguish and think about things that might otherwise remain blurred together.